Florida Mortgage News

Working with Builders while using your Realtor and Mortgage Loan Originator

November 18th, 2015 11:29 PM by Gerald Bliss

So you want to purchase a brand new home. The home you want is going to be built in a brand new subdivision. You sit down with the sales person and you go over the floor plans. He takes you and your fiance to see the model homes and you walk through the showroom. The room looks amazing and you are overwhelmed by the new home smell and the thought of you and your family having your very own new home. Now, it's time to discuss price. You have already done your homework and you've been pre-approved by your Mortgage Loan Originator. You already know what you are looking for. The sales person tells you that you're going to get $15,000.00 in upgrades for free or he tells you that you're going to get $8,000.00 towards your closing costs. You leave, you think about it, and you go over your finances. You and your significant other decide on it and go back to agree on the price and you now want to sign the contract and move forward, but when you go to sign, the sales person says "Oh, but that incentive is only if you use our preferred lender."

Now What?

There are two scenarios that come out from this situation and most of the time, the buyer caves in and just goes with the "preferred lender." What would you do if I told you that this is something the same thing as negotiating with a car salesman? Would you just use the in-house lender at the car dealership because the "sales price" is only available for customers who use their lender? No. That actually sounds ridiculous when you think about it. So why do buyers cave in when going to a builder? The other outcome is that you stick to your plan and negotiate the price, closing costs, and tell them that you're using your own lender. 

Recently, I have seen three builders and three different outcomes. I don't know if I should call out the builder, because we are actually doing business with them now. Here are the three different outcomes:

The Builder works with the lender without hesitation:
"ABC" Homes worked with my buyer without hesitation. The salesperson did offer their in-house lender, but when the buyer said that they have their own lender and that they are not going to use anyone else, she (the salesperson) did not give my buyer any grief and she still gave my buyer the entire $15,000.00 in upgrades. I commend this builder for their actions, because this is not typical. 

The Builder doesn't give the buyer an option:
One of my buyers went to a builder and wanted to use their own lender and they were told that they have to use their in-house lender or they will not get the $15,000.00 towards their closing costs. The buyer did not want to fight for their right to use their own lender. They basically took the builders word as gospel and went along with it. This seems to be the most common outcome and that's why the builders still use this approach with working with their customers.   

The Builder negotiate with the buyer:
I had a buyer go into "XYZ" Homes with a realtor and with my pre-approval letter to negotiate a new Town Home. The builder told the buyer that they would give her $8,000.00 towards closing costs and gave her a price on the home. This particular day, the buyer and the realtor had been home shopping that day and they saw several homes. The price and the closing costs were compared to the other homes they saw that day. She decided that the best value was to use the builder, but when they went back to sign the contract, the salesperson said "that's only if you use our lender." He did not disclose to the buyer that using the in-house lender was the reason for getting $8,000.00 in closing costs. The buyer was young, but not a pushover. Her, her Mom and the Realtor negotiated for several hours with this salesperson. He tried to strong-arm the buyer, but the final outcome was $3000.00 towards closing costs and several thousand dollars off the purchase price. Most buyers would've caved in and just used the in-house lender. 

The CFPB has cracked down on Mortgage Brokers, Processing companies and Realtors. I think the next wave of crack downs may be on Title Companies and the cozy relationships between Builders and "Preferred Lenders." The buying experience shouldn't be horrible for the buyer and they should be able to use the finance lender of their choice, just like when you go to the car dealership. 

Thank you for reading and tell me your experience with builders. 

Posted by Gerald Bliss on November 18th, 2015 11:29 PM